Global / Online
Brown Butter Cookie Company
Ocean Avenue
Sisters Christa and Traci Pister began this bakery in Cayucos in 2004, baking shortbread rounds from slow-browned butter and finishing each with a pinch of sea salt for a caramelized, nutty bite. The shop turns out flavors from original and cocoa to citrus and espresso, boxing tins for shipping across the country.
Best for — Salted brown butter shortbread cookies
Cayucos, California
ORBIS tier: Hidden Gem
In this atlas
✓ Personally verified — crawled twice, human-checked · July 2026 · no store paid to be here