United StatesThe Americas
Cayuga Lake Creamery
Interlaken, NY & DeWitt Mall, downtown Ithaca, NY
Founded in 2004 on the Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, this creamery rotates through more than 200 house-made ice cream flavors, with about 30 available at any time, led by a signature Seneca Salt Caramel. A second scoop shop opened inside downtown Ithaca's historic DeWitt Mall in November 2020.
Best for — Rotating small-batch ice cream flavors
Interlaken, NY
Your atlas
✓ Personally verified — crawled twice, human-checked · July 2026 · no store paid to be here