United StatesThe Americas
Peppers of Key West
Greene Street, Old Town
This Greene Street shop stocks a tasting-bar wall of hundreds of hot sauces and pepper products organized by pepper variety, from mild cayenne blends to ghost-pepper extracts, letting shoppers sample before they buy. It ships its own house-label sauces nationwide alongside jams, mustards, and salsas built around Florida-grown peppers.
Best for — Sampling and buying hot sauce by pepper variety at the tasting bar
Key West, Florida
Your atlas
✓ Personally verified — crawled twice, human-checked · July 2026 · no store paid to be here